Cloth diapers have real benefits, but most of what you’ll read about them comes from people selling them. This article starts with the downsides: what tends to frustrate families, who it affects most, and what you can do about each one. The benefits come after.
The Downsides of Cloth Diapers
More laundry, every few days
This is the big one. Most families wash diapers every two to three days. That usually means a prewash and a long main wash, then drying, and for pocket diapers, stuffing inserts back in. It isn’t hard work, but it’s regular, and you can’t skip it for a week when life gets busy.
You handle poop more directly
Exclusively breastfed poop can usually go straight into the wash. But once your baby is on formula or solids, you’ll need to get poop into the toilet before washing, by knocking, scraping, or spraying it off. Liners and sprayers make this easier. Still, it’s more hands-on than rolling up a disposable.
Higher upfront cost
A full-time stash can cost a few hundred dollars or more at the start, depending on the style. Cloth often works out cheaper over time, but that only matters if you keep using it. Our cost breakdown of cloth vs disposables shows when the savings are bigger or smaller.
A real learning curve
There’s new vocabulary (prefold, AI2, PUL), lots of conflicting advice about washing, and some trial and error to get the fit right. Many families feel comfortable after a few weeks, but the start can be overwhelming. Our cloth diapering basics guide is a good place to begin.
Bulk and clothing fit
Cloth diapers are bulkier than disposables. Some fitted pants and bodysuits won’t close or will squeeze the diaper, and squeezing can cause leaks. You may need to size up or choose stretchier clothes. See our guide to clothes that fit over cloth diapers.
More frequent changes and leaks while you learn
Cloth doesn’t contain the absorbent gel that disposables use, so it generally needs changing more often, often every two to three hours in the day. Leaks are common at first, usually from fit, fabric poking out of the cover, or a diaper that’s simply full. Our explainer on whether pee goes through cloth diapers covers the common causes.
Overnight can be tricky
Getting a cloth diaper to last through the night (10 to 12 hours) often means adding hemp boosters, switching to a fitted, or using a wool cover. Some families never quite solve it and use disposables at night.
Outings and travel take more planning
You’ll carry clean diapers out and bring dirty ones home in a wet bag. On longer trips, you’ll need either laundry access or a switch to disposables for a while.
Daycare and caregiver resistance
Some daycares decline cloth, and some relatives or babysitters are reluctant to use it. Policies vary a lot. Our guide to cloth diapering at daycare has suggestions for those conversations.
Smell and buildup problems
If diapers aren’t getting fully clean, you can end up with ammonia smells, a “barnyard” stink, or diapers that stop absorbing. Fixing it usually means adjusting your detergent amount, wash cycle, or water treatment. Working out the cause can take some troubleshooting.
Restrictions on rash creams
Some ointments, especially those heavy in petroleum or mineral oil, can build up in diaper fabric and reduce absorbency. You may need cloth-friendly creams or a liner. See our guide to rash creams safe for cloth diapers.
Not ideal without easy laundry access
Using a shared laundry room or a laundromat is possible, and some families hand-wash. But each of these adds time, cost, and hassle. Without a washer at home, the savings can shrink quickly.
Newborn fit
Many one-size diapers don’t fit small newborns well until they gain some weight. You may need newborn-sized diapers for a few weeks, or disposables until the one-size diapers fit.
The Upsides, Briefly
- Potential cost savings, especially if you reuse diapers for another child or resell them.
- Far fewer diapers in the trash. A baby can go through thousands of disposables before potty training.
- More control over materials against your baby’s skin, such as cotton, hemp, or wool.
- You never run out as long as you keep up with laundry.
- Many families find blowouts less frequent with well-fitted cloth, because the leg and back elastics hold things in.
- Some parents feel children notice wetness more in cloth, which might help with potty training. Evidence for this is mostly anecdotal.
Are Cloth or Disposable Diapers Better for the Environment?
It’s less clear-cut than many cloth brands suggest. Cloth sends far less to landfill. But washing and drying use water and energy, and the total environmental impact depends heavily on your habits. Life-cycle studies, including assessments done for the UK Environment Agency, found that reusables can come out better or worse than disposables depending on how they’re laundered.
The habits that tend to lower the footprint of cloth include:
- running full loads
- washing at sensible temperatures
- line-drying when you can
- not buying far more diapers than you need
- reusing the diapers for later children
How Long Can You Use Cloth Diapers?
Cloth diapers can be used from birth (with newborn sizes) through potty training. Many one-size diapers are rated up to around 35 pounds. A well-cared-for stash can often last through more than one child, though elastics and waterproof layers wear out over time. Replacing elastic is possible on some styles.
Who Tends to Find Cloth Hardest
- Families without a washer at home
- Parents who are already stretched thin on time and sleep, and have little help
- Babies in a daycare that won’t accept cloth
- Families who travel often
- Very heavy wetters, especially overnight. This is solvable but takes some experimenting.
None of these rule cloth out. They just make it harder.
Ways to Soften the Downsides
- Go part-time. Use cloth at home and disposables for nights, outings, or daycare. See our part-time cloth diapering guide.
- Choose easy-wash styles. Prefolds, flats, and covers wash and dry more easily than thick all-in-ones.
- Start small. Try a few diapers before buying a full stash.
- Keep your wash routine simple and consistent.
- Use liners for solids and when you need a cream.
If cloth still doesn’t feel right, that’s fine too. Our overview of diaper alternatives covers other options.