Diaper Types

Cloth Diaper Systems Explained: Finding the Best Type for Your Baby

Compare every reusable cloth diaper system, from flats and prefolds to pockets, all-in-ones and AI2s, and find the best fit for your budget, baby and routine.

On this page
  1. The Two Jobs Every Cloth Diaper Does
  2. The Main Cloth Diaper Systems at a Glance
  3. Two Decisions That Sit on Top of the System: Closures and Sizing
  4. How to Choose the Best System for Your Family
  5. Mixing Systems Is Normal
  6. Downsides of Reusable Diapers to Weigh Honestly
  7. Are Cloth or Disposable Diapers Better?
  8. Quick Answers

There is no single “best” cloth diaper system. There is a best system for your budget, your laundry setup, your baby’s shape and the people who’ll be changing diapers. The good news is that every modern system works. The differences come down to cost, convenience, drying time and how much you want to customize.

This guide walks through each reusable cloth diaper system, compares them side by side, and then helps you match one (or a mix) to your situation.

The Two Jobs Every Cloth Diaper Does

Every cloth diaper, from a 1950s flat to a modern all-in-one, has to do two things:

  1. Absorb. Something soaks up urine and holds it: cotton, bamboo, hemp, microfiber or a blend.
  2. Stay waterproof. Something stops that moisture from reaching clothes and bedding, usually a PUL or TPU layer, wool, or fleece.

The “systems” are just different ways of packaging those two jobs. Some keep them separate (a prefold plus a cover). Some sew them together (an all-in-one). Others sit in between. Once you see it that way, the choices make a lot more sense.

The Main Cloth Diaper Systems at a Glance

System Pieces Upfront cost Ease for caregivers Drying speed Customizable absorbency
Flats Flat + cover (+ fastener optional) Lowest Learning curve Fastest High
Prefolds Prefold + cover (+ fastener optional) Low Moderate Fast High
Fitteds Fitted + cover Moderate to high Moderate Slow Moderate
Pockets Shell + inserts (stuffed ahead) Moderate Easy once stuffed Fast High
All-in-ones (AIO) One piece Highest per change Easiest Slowest Low to moderate
All-in-twos (AI2) Shell + snap-in or lay-in insert Moderate Easy Fast High

Flats and Prefolds

Flats are large single-layer squares of cotton (birdseye, gauze, muslin, flour-sack or knit) that you fold to size. Prefolds are rectangles with extra layers already sewn into the middle panel. Both need a waterproof cover. They are the cheapest way to cloth diaper, are easy to get clean, and dry quickly. The tradeoff is folding. Many parents simply fold them into thirds and lay them in a cover, which is quick. Our guide to flats, prefolds, gauze and trifolding covers fabrics, sizing and folds.

Fitted Diapers

A fitted looks like a disposable diaper made entirely of absorbent fabric, with elastic at the legs and back and often snaps or hook and loop. Because the whole diaper absorbs, fitteds are a popular overnight choice and are very good at containing newborn poop. They still need a cover over the top, and they take longer to dry. See our article on fitted cloth diapers like Workhorse and Sloomb.

Pocket Diapers

A pocket diaper is a waterproof shell with a soft stay-dry lining sewn inside, leaving an opening you stuff with inserts. Once stuffed, it goes on in one step like a disposable. You can add or remove inserts for naps and nights. The main chore is stuffing after laundry and pulling the inserts out before washing. Read how pocket diapers work and who they suit.

All-in-Ones

An all-in-one (AIO) has the absorbent layers sewn into the waterproof shell. Nothing to stuff or assemble, which is why AIOs are often the easiest choice for daycare, grandparents and anyone nervous about cloth. They usually cost the most per change and take the longest to dry. Our all-in-one guide, including the GroVia O.N.E., looks at designs and fabrics.

All-in-Twos and Hybrids

An all-in-two (AI2) pairs a waterproof shell with an insert that snaps or lays inside. If the baby only wets, you can often wipe the shell, put in a fresh insert and reuse it. That means fewer shells than changes and a lower total cost than AIOs. “Hybrid” is sometimes used for AI2s that also accept a disposable insert. Learn more in our guide to AI2 and snap-in insert systems like Best Bottoms.

Covers: PUL, Wool and Fleece

Flats, prefolds and fitteds all need a cover. Most are made from PUL (polyurethane laminated fabric) or TPU and can be wiped and reused between changes. Wool covers are breathable and work well overnight. They need hand washing and occasional lanolizing. Fleece covers are inexpensive, breathable and easy to sew. Compare them in our pieces on cloth diaper covers and PUL, how to lanolize wool covers and fleece diaper covers.

Two Decisions That Sit on Top of the System: Closures and Sizing

Once you’ve chosen a system, two more choices affect day-to-day life.

Closures. Most modern diapers and covers close with snaps or hook and loop (often called Velcro or Aplix). Hook and loop is quicker and very intuitive. Snaps last longer and are harder for toddlers to undo. Flats and prefolds can be fastened with a Snappi or pins, or simply folded into a cover. See snaps vs hook and loop and Snappi vs diaper pins.

Sizing. One-size diapers use rows of rise snaps to fit roughly 8 to 35 pounds or more, so one stash can last for years. Sized diapers come in newborn, small, medium and so on. They often fit more trimly, but you buy more than once. Read one-size vs sized cloth diapers and our walkthrough on adjusting rise snaps.

How to Choose the Best System for Your Family

Start with your top priority. Most families can name one quickly.

Lowest Cost

Flats or prefolds with a handful of covers are usually the least expensive full-time setup. They are also the easiest to find secondhand. If you want to plan quantities, see how many prefolds you need.

Easiest for Caregivers and Daycare

All-in-ones are the closest to a disposable. Pre-stuffed pockets come next. Hook and loop closures can make them even easier for people who rarely use cloth. Check your daycare’s policy first, since some have specific requirements.

Newborns

Newborns need frequent changes and have runny poop. Prefolds or flats wrapped and fastened, newborn-size fitteds, and small sized AIOs tend to fit best. Many one-size diapers are bulky until a baby reaches around 8 to 12 pounds, depending on the brand and the baby.

Overnight and Heavy Wetters

Systems that let you add absorbency work best: fitteds under wool or fleece, pockets stuffed with hemp or bamboo, or AI2s with a booster. Our article on what diaper holds the most pee overnight goes into detail.

Fast Drying or Line Drying

If you line dry or have a slow dryer, choose systems that come apart: flats, prefolds, pockets and AI2s. Thick sewn-in AIOs can take a long time to dry fully.

Mixing Systems Is Normal

Very few families use one system for every change. A common pattern is prefolds and covers at home, AIOs or pockets for outings and caregivers, and a fitted with wool at night. If you’re unsure, buy a few of two or three types before committing to a full stash. A trial set costs far less than a full stash in the wrong style.

Downsides of Reusable Diapers to Weigh Honestly

Cloth works well for many families, but it isn’t effortless:

  • Laundry. Most families wash every two to three days. You need reliable access to a washing machine, or the willingness to hand wash flats.
  • Upfront cost. Even a budget stash is a bigger one-time spend than a box of disposables.
  • Learning curve. Fit, wash routines and troubleshooting leaks take some practice.
  • Bulk. Cloth is generally bulkier than disposables, so some pants fit differently.
  • Out-of-home changes. You carry the dirty diaper home in a wet bag.

Are Cloth or Disposable Diapers Better?

Neither is better for every family. Cloth can cost less over time, especially if you reuse it for more than one child or resell it. It also cuts the number of diapers going to landfill. Disposables are more convenient and absorb more in a thinner diaper. Environmental comparisons depend heavily on how cloth is washed and dried, so it’s hard to name a clear winner. Many families use both: cloth at home, disposables for travel or nights.

Quick Answers

Do doctors recommend cloth diapers? Pediatric guidance generally treats both cloth and disposable diapers as acceptable. The more important factors for skin health are frequent changes and keeping the diaper area clean and dry. If your baby has a persistent rash, talk to your pediatrician.

Do they still make cloth diapers? Yes. Many brands make modern cloth diapers, and they are sold online, in specialty shops and secondhand. See who still makes cloth diapers and where to buy them.

Does size 1 mean 1 month? No. Diaper sizes, cloth or disposable, are based on weight rather than age. Always check the weight range on the package or product page.

What are the top diaper brands? In cloth, widely available names include Thirsties, GroVia, bumGenius, Kanga Care (Rumparooz), Esembly, Green Mountain Diapers (Cloth-eez), OsoCozy, Smart Bottoms and Nicki’s Diapers (Best Bottom), among many others. The best brand is the one that fits your baby. Fit varies more between babies than between labels.

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →