Washing

Diaper Pails for Cloth Diapers: Ubbi vs Diaper Genie

Can you use an Ubbi or Diaper Genie for cloth diapers? How each works with reusable liners, why airflow matters, odor fixes, and simpler pail alternatives.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What cloth diapers need from a pail
  3. Ubbi diaper pail with cloth diapers
  4. Diaper Genie with cloth diapers
  5. Ubbi vs Diaper Genie for cloth: comparison table
  6. Alternatives that many cloth families use
  7. Why wet pails aren’t recommended
  8. Choosing a pail size
  9. Caring for the pail and liner

The short answer

  • Ubbi: works reasonably well for cloth diapers with a reusable pail liner, since it doesn’t require special bags. Its tight seal can trap moisture, though, so some families crack the lid or empty it more often.
  • Diaper Genie: designed around its own disposable refill bags and a narrow opening. You can make it work with third-party reusable liners, but most cloth diaperers find it awkward.
  • Many cloth families use neither. A plain step trash can, an open hamper, or a hanging wet bag, each with a washable liner, is simpler and cheaper.

What cloth diapers need from a pail

Disposable diaper pails are built to seal smell in, because the diapers go to the trash. Cloth diapers go to the washing machine every two or three days, which changes what matters:

  • Easy emptying. You need to dump the whole load into the washer, ideally by tipping the liner in without touching the diapers.
  • A washable liner that goes in the wash with the diapers.
  • Some airflow. A sealed container keeps damp diapers humid, and some cloth diaperers find that makes ammonia smells and mildew worse. Many people prefer a pail that’s lidded but not airtight, or one with an open top.
  • Enough capacity for two to three days of diapers.

Ubbi diaper pail with cloth diapers

The Ubbi is a steel pail with a sliding lid and rubber seals. Steel doesn’t absorb odors the way some plastics can, which is one reason it’s popular.

What bags go in an Ubbi?

The Ubbi doesn’t need proprietary bags. For disposables, people commonly use regular kitchen trash bags. For cloth, use a reusable pail liner, usually a waterproof PUL drawstring bag sized for a standard tall kitchen bin. Ubbi has sold its own cloth liner, and many cloth diaper brands make liners that fit similar-sized pails. Check the liner’s dimensions against the pail before buying.

Why does my Ubbi smell?

The most common causes with cloth diapers:

  • Trapped moisture. The seal that keeps smells in also keeps humidity in. Leaving the lid slightly open, or using a liner made of breathable fabric, may help.
  • Too long between washes. Waiting more than about three days lets ammonia build up.
  • A liner that needs washing. Wash the liner with every diaper load, and keep a spare so the pail is never without one.
  • The pail itself. Wipe the inside of the pail and lid now and then. A seal or lid can hold residue.
  • The diapers. If the pail smells strongly of ammonia, the diapers may not be getting fully clean in the wash. See why cloth diapers smell like ammonia.

Some people sprinkle baking soda in the bottom of the pail. If you try this, keep it in the pail itself rather than on the diapers, and check your diaper brand’s guidance. Heavily scented sprays or deodorizer discs placed on the diapers are best avoided.

Is the Ubbi worth it for cloth?

It can be, especially if you like having a single pail that works for both cloth and the occasional disposable. It’s more expensive than a basic step can, though, and its main advantage, the sealed lid, matters less for cloth. If budget is a factor, a step can with a reusable liner does essentially the same job for cloth.

Diaper Genie with cloth diapers

The Diaper Genie is designed around a continuous refill bag. Diapers drop through a narrow opening and the bag twists or seals them off. That design works well for disposables but clashes with cloth:

  • The narrow opening and internal mechanism make dropping in bulky cloth diapers awkward, and emptying them into the washer even more so.
  • Using the disposable refill bags for cloth means pulling diapers back out of plastic, and it adds ongoing cost and waste.
  • Some sellers make reusable fabric liners for Diaper Genie models. Fit varies, and you’ll still be working around the mechanism.

If you already own a Diaper Genie, it may still be useful for disposable wipes, diapers you use on outings, or a later child in disposables. For cloth, most families find another option easier.

Ubbi vs Diaper Genie for cloth: comparison table

Ubbi Diaper Genie
Needs special bags No Designed for its own refills
Works with reusable liners Yes, standard drawstring liners Only with third-party liners, with limits
Easy to dump into the washer Yes Awkward
Airflow Low (sealed) Low (sealed)
Best fit for cloth Reasonable Poor

Alternatives that many cloth families use

Step trash can with a reusable liner

A foot-pedal trash can of about the same size as a kitchen bin, plus one or two PUL pail liners, is probably the most common cloth setup. It’s cheap, hands-free, and easy to empty. Pick one with a lid that doesn’t seal tightly.

Open pail or hamper

Some families use an open laundry hamper or basket with a liner. More airflow can mean fewer ammonia problems and drier diapers, at the cost of more smell in the room. This setup works best in a laundry room or bathroom.

Hanging pail bag / wet bag

A large zippered wet bag or “hanging pail” with a handle can hang on a doorknob or hook. It takes up little floor space, and the whole bag goes into the wash. A small wet bag is also useful in the diaper bag for changes away from home (see our cloth diapering essentials checklist).

If you use liners for poop, our article on dealing with cloth diaper poop explains what to remove before anything goes in the pail.

Older cloth diapering advice suggested soaking dirty diapers in a bucket of water, sometimes with bleach or other additives. Most current guidance recommends a dry pail instead:

  • A bucket of water is a drowning hazard for babies and toddlers, who can tip into it headfirst.
  • Soaking diapers are heavy, sloshy and messy to move.
  • Long soaks can be hard on elastic and waterproof fabric, and standing water can grow bacteria.

Choosing a pail size

Plan for two to three days of dirty diapers. Newborns go through many more diapers per day than older babies, and cloth diapers are bulkier than disposables. A pail around the size of a standard tall kitchen bin is a common choice. A smaller pail may be fine for an older baby with fewer changes, or if you wash more often.

Caring for the pail and liner

  • Wash the liner with every diaper load, inside out if the care instructions allow, and line dry or low dry it like other PUL items.
  • Keep two liners so one is always in the pail.
  • Wipe or rinse the pail periodically, and let it air out.
  • Avoid fabric softener and dryer sheets on liners, just as with diapers.

For the full routine once the pail is full, see our step-by-step guide to washing cloth diapers.

The complete guide to washing

How to Wash Cloth Diapers: A Complete Wash Routine
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →